The Books and movie versions of "Lord of the Rings: King's Return" Have many similarities, but also some great differences. Peter Acksexon's "King's Return" adaptation makes some big changes To JRR Tolkien's source material, how to reduce Shire's penetration (Hobbit's uprising to regain his homeland from Saruman's forces). However, Tolkien's novel and Acksecson's novel conclude that Frodo left the middle country. Why? Other hobbies, how Happy and Pippin, get less dramatic (though you are still moving) ends.

So why should you leave the hero hobbit on a bag? Everything is fine, right? The short answer is that Frodo is leaving the middle country because ... In fact, I will allow him to explain. Here's how he justifies his beloved Sam's move on the latest pages of Tolkien's book:

"I was too deeply injured, Sam. I tried to save Shire, and it's preserved, but not for me. Often it has to be the case, when things are in danger: one has to give up, lose them so that others can keep them."

Earlier, Frodo went a little more detail when he talked to Gandalf about his "deep hurts". When they passed Ford on Brunin (where black drivers attacked Frodo early in his quest), Frodo's old wound in shoulder pain, and Gandalf replies: "Unfortunately, there are some wounds that cannot be completely cured," Frodo responds:

"There is no real return. Although I may come to Shire, it won't seem the same to me; because I won't be the same. I'm wounded with a knife, sting and tooth and a long burden. Where will I find a vacation?"

The answer, of course, is above the seas, in the west, in non -permanent countries. Let's break things down.

Frodo is successful in its search, but not without a price. Black drivers stab it on Weathertop. Later, he is stabbed with a knife in his neck, and his body is flooded with her poison. Golum bit his finger. Should I continue? Frodo spends the months on the search passing through the ring.

And this is just the physical side of things. He comes very close to succumbing to the world of Wright in the weeks following his wound on the knife. Who knows what kind of demon threat is facing Shellob. And let's not forget the one who is a kinky ring. It weighs something for 17 years in Tolkien's original books before leaving for his quest, and then only becomes more difficult when he approaches Doom Mountain. His mind and spirit are destroyed by experience. Believe me, if you've only seen Acksexon films, it's hard to grasp the weight of Frodo's victim. (There's a reason I made the case for a few years back why He is the real hero of the storyEven if Tolkien technically chose Sam.)

There is a point in the "King's Return", when Frodo and Sam get into the Doom Mountain, where we will look at Frodo's inner struggle. It's in the movie, but the book version is the best. Here's what Frodo says:

"No taste of food, there is a feeling of water, no wind sound, no wood or grass or flower memory, I have no moon or a starvet image.

Frodo's experience during the ring war spoils him mentally, spiritually and physically, to the extent that he even gets sick on the anniversary of some of his wounds. But it gets worse.

In a letter to a fan in September 1963, Explain Tolkien Frodo's thinking after a ring is destroyed. First, he feels facilitated, returned to reasonability and close to death. When he survives and healed, he begins to become restless. Arwen notes first, so she gives her a gem as a source of comfort ... and put a mistake in her ear for potential walking to the west to find healing. After Tolkien:

It is not only memorizing the nights of the past horrors they came across, but also unreasonable self-reproduction: he saw himself and everything he did as a broken failure. "

When Frodo says it will not be the same, even if he returns to Shire, he actually reflects dark (Tolkien uses the "D" area) and an internal sense of pride that he does not return as a sincere hero, but only a "instrument of good". There is even some of him that one ring still wants after it has disappeared. As Tolkien once said:

Frodo was sent or allowed to pass over the sea to heal it - if it could be done before he died. He would eventually have to "pass" (...), so he went to the purgatory and prize, for some time: a period of thinking and peace and gaining a true understanding of his position in light and in greatness. "

In the end, Frodo goes to the west to heal, learn his place and get a slight return from his long papers.