Dennis Vilnuiv inadvertently achieved an impressive feat with his first two films "Dune". Finally, he reportedly gave Frank Herbert's "incessant" novel, a "incessantly" novel in 1965, a worthy adaptation of a large canvas, the French Canadian director somehow managed to make his unique vision while remaining faithful to the author's original story.

Wilneevay was clearly loyal to Herbert's writing, but it wasn't so precious that his films didn't make changes to the novel. In places, the director and his team were able to make their own creative decisions, such as when designer Patrice Vemet based in the look of the king of the king Jaddam on the Rolex clock. Elsewhere, cinematographer Grig Fraser shot the exterior of Harconen's domestic planet, Gives Premier with infrared cameras To produce a monochrome image that reflects the black surface of the sun in the world. All of these were the creative decisions that the team had to make to bring Herbert's words to life in a visual medium. But the other moments both in "Duna" and "Duna: Part Two" simply moved away from the original novel completely.

For one thing, The main death "Duna: Part Two" differs quite dramatically from the book. In the film, Baron Vladimir Harconen at Stellan Scarsgard was killed by Paul Atreids by Timote Halamet, not, as described in the book, by his sister Alia. In fact, Alia wasn't born either in Vilnev's movies, instead of appearing in the flash sequences in which she played Anja Taylor-Hoy in the look of Kimo. Then, Vilnev was clearly aware of the fact that he first made a movie, not only following Herbert's exact words. It was also manifested elsewhere, also with the director to choose to retain the backstew of Zendaya's warrior, Fremen Warrior Jani, ambiguous, though, in the novel, she has been confirmed that she is the granddaughter of Fremen Style leader (Javier Bardem). But does that mean that the film version of Canie is not related to Stylish? Or, Vilnev has only been keeping that aspect of the story for the time being?

In Frank Herbert's "Duna" books, Janie He was the daughter of a semi-flamed planetologist named Lit Kines and Fremen Herbalist Farula. She continued to fight for her people under the guidance of her uncle, Stilagar, who was the brother of Lit Kines. Both in the novel "Duna" and in the two-piece film adaptation of Danny Wilneevay, Stilgar is Naib, which means he is the leader of the frem SIT or the community-group that was joined by Paul Atreid after his clan was destroyed by Harconens on the planet.

However, in the films, the relationship between Stilgar and Canie - who becomes a Lubodnik of Paul, as the story unfolds - remains unclear. While the two are clearly close, it is never clear that Canie is the granddaughter of Stilgar. Vilnev actually made some major changes to Zendaya. For one thing, her warrior Frentmen is a more cynical version of her colleague than the book, looking through the worship of Paul Atries and remains incredible, as he seems to fulfill Fremen's prophecies to Lisan al-Gaib. Moreover, director Rodovi has hit the image of Lit Kien, who is an imperial planetologist played by Sharon Duncan-Bruzster. As Vilnev seems to have confirmed Fun weeklyJanie is still the daughter of Kines, though this link is never mentioned in any film. Until the exit quotes the director directly, the article itself is based on a conversation with Vilnev, so this seems like a pretty solid indicator that Kines and Canie are connected.

What does not confirm, however, is whether Stilgar is also linked to Kines in film versions of "Duna". As such, it remains unclear whether she is Fanny, really the granddaughter of Fremen Naib in the films of Vilnev.

In "Duna: Part Two", we see that Canie is getting more worried about the way her people accept Paul Atries as a messianic figure. During the film, she remains skeptical about the growing delight of Fremen for her new lubricity, and in the last moments her worries seem to be confirmed because Paul announces that she will marry the daughter of Christopher Walken's Emperor, Haddam IV, Princess Irulan (Florence).

Meanwhile, Stilgar is everything in the prophecy of Lisan al -Gaib, who tells of the saving figure arriving to lead Fremen. He and Canie actually clash with their various views of the prophecy - something Vilnev played for the film, but what is not so much a problem in the novel. Does this lack of common belief in the prophecy hint at the two of which are completely different and, therefore, completely different families? Maybe, but again, it is not entirely clear whether the collision of Canie and Stilagar will deteriorate from the idea they make, in fact, come from the same family.

Vilnev has yet to clarify something of this, and that is probably for good reason. The director clearly has his own vision of the Duna saga and has already made at least one major change in Canie's backstew with the gender Lit Kitts. With "Dune 3" that is fast tracking During writing, it may not be that long until we discover the truth whether Cani and Stilagar of the films are connected or not, (though Villnev is, of course, under any obligation to reveal the answer at all).