During Star Trek: Strange new worlds "Subspace Rhapsody" blew up the music scene, and for most fans of the genre, it can't compare. Buffy the Vampire SlayerAn episode of the musical masterpiece “Once Upon A Time With Feelings. That Buffy Episode 1 combines crazy-sounding earworm tunes with character-driven plot twists, making it the gold standard for musical episodes. If we're being honest, the Star Trek musical is even less so. BuffyIn almost every way except one: "Subspace Rhapsody" features the main cast singing, while "Once Upon a Time" has two actors refusing to sing.
Buffy's musical mistake
Before the Star Trek musical episode aired, Buffy"Once with a feeling" almost all gave the leaders their own songs. Buffy channels rising stars as she sings about survival, Jills does a power ballad about having her back, Spike becomes a rock star to explain his mixed feelings about a killer, and so on. However, Hannigan's Willow does not have a song of her own. In fact, she only has two lines of music, including the hilariously meta lyric "I think this line fills most of it."
As for why Willow didn't appear on the soundtrack, showrunner Joss Whedon Hannigan said, "She got down on her knees and asked me to sing as little as possible." He accepts that request, which is why Tara performs the entire song in their magical love song, "Under Your Spell." Meanwhile, he's the only main cast member who doesn't sing. Michelle Trachtenbergthat she asked to use her ballet training and perform a dance sequence instead.
Star Trek's musical masterstroke
As we've seen before, the Star Trek musical pales in comparison. BuffyIn most ways. The songs aren't catchy, the emotional highs aren't that high, and certain plot points occasionally fall flat. However, there is exactly one place Star Trek Ups and downs Buffy In the music department: all the main actors sing. Sure, some vocals are stronger than others, but it's no surprise that no one backs down, especially considering Trek has never done a musical before and expectations are extremely high.
Later Star Trek: Strange New Worlds He brought us the much-missed "Subspace Rhapsody," with showrunners Henry Alonso Myers and Akiva Goldsman giving interviews to various; They were surprised that all the actors were there to sing. According to Goldsman, "we ended up with an absurdly good play" and he was expecting a "dude in a band" who wouldn't sing or sing. Instead, he concluded, "it was as if they had all lived their lives secretly yearning for the idea of music."
Spook songs
It helped that these Star Trek showrunners had the opposite problem. BuffyIt had producers. Instead of finding someone like Hannigan uncomfortable singing on screen, they discovered that one of their biggest stars was secretly a musical maestro. Discussing Spock Actor Ethan Peck, Goldsman, said, "As far as Ethan goes, 'Holy f***, Ethan can sing!' I didn't know he could sing. Hilariously, he revealed that his reaction was basically the same as the audience watching the famous Vulcan sing for the first time: "You're like, 'Wait, Spock's singing now?' you say.
As it stands, Star Trek's first musical episode isn't as popular. BuffyAnd for good reason. At the end of the day, the songs the Enterprise crew sing aren't nearly as fun or exciting as the ones sung by Sunnydale's Scooby Gang. however, Strange new worlds All of the lead actors can be proud of the fact that they stepped up to sing their hearts out. Buffy It kept the two actors out of the spotlight (albeit at their own request). And that's something worth singing about once again with emotion. Although these feelings, as Spock reminds us, are completely irrational.
Source: Difference
Source link